Research-Backed Methodology

The BTNG E-commerce UX Framework

60 research-backed criteria across 6 page types. Based on 20 years of e-commerce UX experience and published research, including Nielsen Norman Group and Google.

Scoring System

How Scoring Works

Each criterion is a YES/NO question. We weight by importance to calculate your score.

Critical

Failing these hurts conversions significantly.3 points each

Important

Missing these creates friction.2 points each

Nice-to-have

These differentiate good from great.1 point each

Score Scale

How we interpret your overall score

90%+

Excellent

Score range

70-89%

Good

Score range

50-69%

Needs Work

Score range

<50%

Poor

Score range

Audit Output

What You Get From Each Audit

Every evaluation produces three actionable lists

Things We Like

Criteria the site passes that are well-implemented. Celebrate these and maintain them.

Things We're Missing

Criteria the site fails on — clear opportunities for improvement and quick wins.

Things We Don't Like

Criteria the site fails on AND the implementation is actively harmful to UX.

Full Criteria List

Every question we ask when evaluating an e-commerce site

Homepage

The main landing page of the website

1 Critical3 Important6 Nice-to-have
Hero & Value Proposition2 criteria
Critical

Does the homepage clearly communicate what the site sells within the first viewport?

Users form impressions in 1/10 second; 2-3 seconds to understand offering

Clear value proposition immediately visibleUnclear what the site sells at first glance

Source: Baymard Institute

Important

Is there a prominent, action-oriented CTA in the hero section with contrasting color?

Hero CTAs drive primary conversion paths

Strong hero call-to-actionHero section lacks a clear call-to-action

Source: Google Retail UX

Navigation3 criteria
Important

Are main product categories directly visible in the navigation (not hidden under a generic "Shop" menu)?

Hidden categories reduce discoverability

Categories accessible directly from navigationCategories hidden under generic menu

Source: Baymard Institute

Important

Is the search function prominently visible in the header?

30%+ of users prefer search over navigation

Search easily accessible in headerSearch function not prominently visible

Source: Baymard Institute

Nice-to-have

Does the mega menu reveal subcategories on hover/click?

Reduces clicks to reach products

Subcategories accessible via mega menuNo mega menu to preview subcategories

Source: Baymard Institute

Trust & Communication3 criteria
Nice-to-have

Is there a USP bar communicating key benefits (shipping, returns, support)?

Sets expectations and reduces purchase anxiety

Key benefits clearly communicatedNo USP bar highlighting shipping, returns, or support

Source: Nielsen Norman Group

Nice-to-have

Is social proof displayed (reviews, testimonials, trust badges, or customer count)?

Builds credibility for first-time visitors

Social proof builds visitor confidenceNo visible social proof or testimonials

Source: Nielsen Norman Group

Nice-to-have

Is contact information easily accessible (including phone or physical address)?

Trust signal, especially for new visitors

Contact information easily foundContact details not readily accessible

Source: Nielsen Norman Group

Product Showcase1 criteria
Nice-to-have

Are featured products or new arrivals shown with prices visible?

Price visibility reduces friction

Featured products show pricing upfrontFeatured products lack visible pricing

Source: Baymard Institute

Performance1 criteria
Nice-to-have

Does the homepage load without layout shifts (stable content positioning)?

CLS affects user experience and SEO

Stable page load without content jumpingLayout shifts during page load

Source: Google Core Web Vitals

Product Detail Page

Individual product pages with full product information

2 Critical7 Important1 Nice-to-have
Pricing & Purchase3 criteria
Critical

Is the price clearly visible above the fold?

Price is #1 decision factor; hiding it causes abandonment

Price immediately visiblePrice not visible above the fold

Source: Baymard Institute

Important

Does the Add to Cart button use a prominent, contrasting color?

Must stand out as primary action

Add to Cart button stands out clearlyAdd to Cart button lacks visual prominence

Source: Baymard Institute

Important

Is there clear visual feedback when an item is added to cart?

Lack of confirmation causes duplicate adds or abandonment

Clear confirmation when adding to cartNo feedback when item added to cart

Source: Nielsen Norman Group

Shipping & Delivery1 criteria
Critical

Are shipping costs or a free shipping threshold shown on this page?

55% of sites fail this; #1 cause of cart abandonment

Shipping costs transparent on product pageNo shipping information until checkout

Source: Baymard Institute

Product Images3 criteria
Important

Are at least 3 product images from different angles available?

Multiple angles reduce returns and increase confidence

Multiple product angles availableInsufficient product imagery

Source: Baymard Institute

Important

Is at least one image shown "in scale" (product in context or with size reference)?

91% of sites fail this; causes returns

Product shown in context for size referenceNo sense of product scale or size

Source: Baymard Institute

Nice-to-have

Is zoom or enlarge functionality available on product images?

Lets users inspect details before buying

Image zoom functionality availableNo image zoom capability

Source: Baymard Institute

Availability1 criteria
Important

Is stock availability clearly indicated (in stock, low stock, or out of stock)?

Prevents frustration and sets expectations

Stock status clearly displayedNo stock availability information

Source: Nielsen Norman Group

Reviews & Ratings1 criteria
Important

Is the star rating displayed near the product title (above the fold)?

Ratings influence 93% of purchase decisions

Rating visible at top of pageRating hidden below the fold

Source: Spiegel Research Center

Trust & Policies1 criteria
Important

Is return policy information accessible from this page (visible or one click away)?

52% fail this; reduces purchase anxiety

Return policy easily accessibleReturn policy not accessible from product page

Source: Baymard Institute

Product Listing Page

Category or collection pages showing multiple products

1 Critical7 Important2 Nice-to-have
Filtering4 criteria
Critical

Can users select multiple values within the same filter (e.g., two sizes or two colors)?

Single-select filters cause 67-90% abandonment

Multi-select filtering supportedFilters limited to single selection only

Source: Baymard Institute

Important

Are applied filters displayed in a clear summary with one-click removal?

32% fail this; users lose track of active filters

Applied filters shown with easy removalNo clear overview of active filters

Source: Baymard Institute

Important

Are filters displayed in a sidebar or expandable panel (not horizontal toolbar only)?

Sidebar filters outperform horizontal-only layouts

Filters accessible in sidebar layoutFilters cramped in horizontal toolbar only

Source: Baymard Institute

Nice-to-have

Is product count shown next to each filter option?

Prevents dead-end filter selections

Filter options show result countsNo product count per filter option

Source: Nielsen Norman Group

Sorting2 criteria
Important

Is sorting by Price available?

Essential sort option; 69% of sites missing at least one core sort

Price sorting availableCannot sort by price

Source: Baymard Institute

Important

Is sorting by Customer Rating available?

High-intent users filter by quality

Rating-based sorting availableCannot sort by customer rating

Source: Baymard Institute

Product Cards2 criteria
Important

Do product cards display the star rating with review count?

Ratings on cards increase click-through

Ratings visible on product cardsNo ratings shown in product grid

Source: Baymard Institute

Important

Do product cards show price (including sale price formatting if applicable)?

Price visibility enables comparison shopping

Prices visible on all product cardsPrices hidden until clicking product

Source: Baymard Institute

Pagination2 criteria
Nice-to-have

Is the total product count displayed on the page?

Helps users understand catalog scope

Total product count displayedNo total product count shown

Source: Nielsen Norman Group

Important

Is scroll position preserved when returning from a product page?

Losing position causes significant frustration

Scroll position maintained on back navigationPage resets to top when returning from product

Source: Baymard Institute

Shopping Cart

Cart page showing selected items

2 Critical1 Important7 Nice-to-have
Cost Transparency2 criteria
Critical

Is the shipping cost (or free shipping threshold) shown before proceeding to checkout?

Unexpected costs cause 48% of cart abandonment

Shipping costs visible in cartShipping costs hidden until checkout

Source: Baymard Institute

Critical

Are all costs visible (subtotal, shipping, taxes, fees) before checkout?

Hidden costs are the #1 abandonment driver

Complete cost breakdown in cartHidden costs surprise customers at checkout

Source: Baymard Institute

Checkout Flow2 criteria
Important

Does the Proceed to Checkout button use a high-contrast, prominent color?

Must be the clear primary action

Checkout button clearly stands outCheckout button lacks visual prominence

Source: Baymard Institute

Nice-to-have

Are express checkout options visible (PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay, etc.)?

Reduces checkout friction for returning users

Express checkout options availableNo express checkout options

Source: Baymard Institute

Cart Management4 criteria
Nice-to-have

Can product quantity be easily modified with +/- controls?

Friction in editing causes abandonment

Easy quantity adjustment with +/- buttonsNo +/- buttons for quantity changes

Source: Nielsen Norman Group

Nice-to-have

Do totals update automatically when quantity changes (no "Update" button required)?

Manual updates feel outdated and cause errors

Cart totals update in real-timeManual update required after quantity change

Source: Nielsen Norman Group

Nice-to-have

Is a product thumbnail image shown for each cart item?

Visual confirmation reduces errors

Product images visible in cartNo product images in cart

Source: Baymard Institute

Nice-to-have

Can items be removed from cart with a single action?

Difficult removal frustrates users

One-click item removalRemoving items requires multiple steps

Source: Nielsen Norman Group

Promotions1 criteria
Nice-to-have

Is the promo/discount code field present but not overly prominent?

Too prominent = users leave to hunt for codes

Balanced promo code field placementPromo field too prominent or completely hidden

Source: Baymard Institute

Cross-sells1 criteria
Nice-to-have

Are cross-sell recommendations limited and positioned below the cart summary?

Intrusive cross-sells distract from checkout

Non-intrusive cross-sell placementCross-sells interrupt the checkout flow

Source: Baymard Institute

Checkout

The checkout flow for completing purchases

2 Critical4 Important4 Nice-to-have
Guest Checkout1 criteria
Critical

Is guest checkout prominently available (not hidden or deprioritized)?

19% abandon when forced to create account

Guest checkout prominently offeredGuest checkout hidden or unavailable

Source: Baymard Institute

Error Handling2 criteria
Critical

Do error messages clearly explain what's wrong and how to fix it?

94% of sites fail this; generic errors cause abandonment

Helpful, actionable error messagesVague error messages without guidance

Source: Baymard Institute

Important

Is inline validation used (errors shown immediately, not only on submit)?

Real-time feedback reduces form errors by 22%

Real-time form validationErrors only appear after form submission

Source: Nielsen Norman Group

Form Design3 criteria
Important

Are form field labels visible above the fields (not placeholder-only)?

Placeholder-only labels cause input errors

Persistent field labels above inputsLabels disappear when typing (placeholder-only)

Source: Baymard Institute

Nice-to-have

Does the correct mobile keyboard appear for each field type (numeric for phone, email for email)?

Wrong keyboard increases mobile abandonment

Optimized mobile keyboards per field typeWrong keyboard type for input fields

Source: Google Mobile UX

Nice-to-have

Is address autocomplete integrated?

Reduces typing effort and errors

Address autocomplete reduces typingNo address autocomplete

Source: Baymard Institute

Progress & Navigation1 criteria
Important

Is there a progress indicator showing current step and total steps?

Reduces perceived effort and abandonment

Clear checkout progress indicatorNo indication of checkout progress

Source: Nielsen Norman Group

Order Summary1 criteria
Important

Is the order summary (with product images and itemized costs) visible throughout checkout?

Reassures users and prevents last-minute doubts

Order summary visible throughout checkoutOrder summary hidden during checkout steps

Source: Baymard Institute

Trust & Security1 criteria
Nice-to-have

Are security badges or trust signals displayed near the payment section?

Payment is highest-anxiety moment

Security badges near payment fieldsNo trust signals at payment step

Source: Baymard Institute

Payment Options1 criteria
Nice-to-have

Are multiple payment methods offered (credit card + at least one alternative)?

Limited options exclude potential customers

Multiple payment options availableLimited payment method options

Source: Baymard Institute

Search Results

Search results page with filtering options

1 Critical5 Important4 Nice-to-have
Relevance1 criteria
Critical

Does the search return relevant results for common product queries?

Poor relevance = immediate abandonment

Search returns relevant resultsSearch results lack relevance

Source: Nielsen Norman Group

Results Display3 criteria
Important

Are search results displayed in a grid with product images, prices, and ratings?

Searchers have high intent; need quick comparison

Rich product cards in search resultsSearch results missing key product info

Source: Baymard Institute

Important

Is the search query displayed on the results page (confirmation of what was searched)?

Confirms intent and enables query refinement

Search query confirmed on results pageUnclear what was searched for

Source: Baymard Institute

Nice-to-have

Is the number of results displayed?

Sets expectations and indicates query success

Result count shownNo indication of how many results found

Source: Nielsen Norman Group

Filtering & Sorting2 criteria
Important

Can users filter search results (same filtering as category pages)?

Searchers often need to narrow results

Filtering available on search resultsCannot filter search results

Source: Baymard Institute

Important

Can users sort search results (by price, rating, relevance)?

Different users prioritize differently

Sort options on search resultsCannot sort search results

Source: Baymard Institute

Search Assistance3 criteria
Nice-to-have

Does the search offer autocomplete suggestions as the user types?

Reduces effort and guides toward valid queries

Search autocomplete assists usersNo autocomplete suggestions

Source: Baymard Institute

Nice-to-have

Are spelling corrections or "Did you mean..." suggestions shown for typos?

Prevents zero-result dead ends

Typo tolerance with suggestionsNo spelling correction for search typos

Source: Algolia Best Practices

Nice-to-have

Does search handle synonyms and plurals correctly?

"Couch" vs "sofa" or "shoe" vs "shoes"

Search understands synonyms and pluralsSearch too literal with terminology

Source: Algolia Best Practices

No Results Handling1 criteria
Important

Is a helpful message shown when there are no results (with suggestions or alternatives)?

Empty state without guidance causes abandonment

Helpful zero-results stateDead-end when no results found

Source: Nielsen Norman Group

About BTNG.studio

This framework was developed by Philip Wallage and the BTNG.studio team based on 20 years of e-commerce UX experience, working with brands across fashion, electronics, home goods, and more. We've distilled research from leading e-commerce UX research, Nielsen Norman Group, Google's Retail UX Playbook, and our own client work into this practical, actionable framework.